- Learning to Adapt With A Professional Reading Program
- Boyd and Beyond 2013
- Guest Post by Tyana Daley: Developing Law Enforcement Leaders and Nurturing Smart Thinkers
- Somewhere Between Born and Made: Where Good Leaders Come From
- Is Today Your Day?
- Guest Post by John Demand: “You look for the bomb…we look for the bomber”
- What Do OODA Loop’s Mean to the Street Cop, Wanting To Become “World Class” Tacticians?
- The Psychology of a Boston Marathon Terrorist: 10 Questions for a Retired Marine
- Watching Boston “Work Together” Made Me Proud to Be a Police Officer
- What Makes a "World Class" Tactically Proficient Peacekeeper?
- Tactical Decision Games to Increase Speed and Maturity of Problem Solving: The Lessons Learned
- The Path to Better Execution in Seeing, Understanding and Solving Complex Problems is a Learning Organization
- A Systemic Concept for Operational Design: a Robust Tool Law Enforcement Should Use in Preparing for Chaotic Crisis
- How shift debriefings can improve officer safety Published at P1
- Boyd and Beyond Boston 2013: Balancing Pursuasion and Force in The Moral, Mental and Physical Dimensions of Conflict
- Don Vandergriff, Discusses: Misinterpretation and Confusion: What is Mission Command?
- Huddling-Up To Acheive Successful Law Enforcement Outcomes
- Building Cohesive Law Enforcement Agencies That Can Decide In Crisis Situations
- Mistakes ultimately ended ex-LA cop's rampage
- Red Teaming The Workplace Violence Shooter and The "MR. Uncomfortable Factor"
- Top 30 Criminal Justice Blogs of 2012 : LESC is Number 5!
- Showing Up Is Overrated. Necessary But Not Nearly Sufficient. Can Taking An "Interest" In What You Do Enhance Performance?
- Handling Dynamic Encounters...Go Get Him, Or Set Him Up To Get Him...With An Adaptable Response
- Shift Debriefings: How Can We Be More Deliberate, More Disciplined, and More Thorough in our Approach to Learning?
- AOW Card Deck Lesson 6: Provoke Your Adversary’s Reaction
- Does Mass Violence Unfold Randomly and Chaotic or is There Hidden Order We Can Leverage in Our Prevention Efforts?
- Police One Column: 13 questions to answer in 2013: What has 2012 taught you about officer safety and effectiveness?
- Take Small Steps, Towards, Lifelong Learning In 2013
- Positive Adaptive Leadership...Tools and Tips and Critical Questions To Explore in 2013 Inspired by Many Of Those I Follow
- AOW Card Deck Lesson 5: Sheath Your Sword
- AOW Card Deck Lesson 4: Score A Small Victory Along The Way
- In Mastering Tactics Shouldn’t We Be Blending Policy and Procedures with People and Ideas?
- Ready, Aim, Ready?
- IMPLEMENTATION (OODA LOOP OR BOYD’S CYCLE) by Sid Heal
- AOW Card Deck Lesson 3: Engage Your Adversary From Many Directions
- AOW Card Deck Lesson 2: Lure The Tiger Out Of The Mountain
- AOW Card Deck Lesson 1: Catch Your Adversary Sleeping
- The Art of War: Sun Tzu Strategy Card Deck…Simple, Yet, Great Tool for Developing Strategic and Tactical Mindset
- "Certain men…come to be accepted guardians and transmitters, instructors, of established doctrines...
- On Vision
- Book Review: The Rite of Return: Coming Back From Duty Induced PTSD
- Restoring the Wounded Spirit
- Deciding Under Pressure…and Fast: You Need to Understand the Concept of “Coup d’oeil”
- How Do Adaptive Leaders Think?
- Capt Evan Bradley on Boyd, Adaptability and Understanding the Bigger Picture in Conflict
- Captain Lindsay Rodman On Boyd and Taking Ownership of What You Do!
- William McNulty-Team Rubicon: Boyd, Applied to Disaster Response
- Heroes Behind the Badge
- Chet Richards On Boyd...Is Your Orientation, Matched to Reality?
- Col GI Wilson on Boyd, Bureaucracy, Insight, Imagination, Intent and Implementation
- What hath Boyd wrought? With Remarks
- John Boyd, Conceptual Spiral, and the meaning of life
- Boyd and Beyond 2012, Quantico, VA — a quickie recap by Scott Shipman
- Finished Gung Ho! The Corps Most Progressive Tradition
- Dangerous Minds – The Relationship between Beliefs, Behaviors, and Tactics
- Guest Post: Super Cops - Can we create them??? “Yes you can!”
- "The importance of a proper command system...
- "Leaders gain confidence and become more tactically and technically proficient...
- Help staff practice thinking on their feet to prepare for emergencies
- More On, Gung Ho! Out of Seeming Defeat May Have Sprung Great Potential
- Latest P1 Column: The anatomy of victory (part two): Victory at minimal cost
- Chapter 1 Review of "Gung Ho! The Corps' Most Progressive Tradition
- Latest P1 Column: The anatomy of victory (part one): What does it take to win?
- Proper Police Action Requires...What?
- P1 Column: Patterns of behavior, officer safety, and 'the rule of opposites'
- Be agile and win:
- Why Boyd is Agile
- Destruction & Creation: Are You Locked on One Way of Thinking or Are You Adaptable, Approaching Tactical Dilemmas?
- Book Review: Deadly Force: Firearms and American Law Enforcement, from the Wild West to the Streets of Today
- The power of a handshake!
- Winning at Low Cost: No better friend, no better role model, no better diplomat and, no worse enemy
- "The most efficient way to get the behavior you're looking for is to find positive deviants and...
- Book Review: Police Instructor: Deliver Dynamic Presentations, Create Engaging Slides & Increase Active Learning
- "Organizations by their very nature involves a series of balances...
- "Of every 100 men you send to fight, 10 shouldn't even be there. Eighty are...
- Column at Police One: Mental toughness and the power to adapt
- Mental Attitude Can Be Negative or Positive
- The Anatomy of Victory: What Does It Take To "Win"at Low Cost?
- "They can't understand why their parent organizations didn't better prepare them...
- Counter-Ambush Tactics: Thinking Tactically and Doing What You Know How To Do On The Street
- Train To Make a Difference! A Decrease in Officer Fatalities in 1st Quarter of 2012
- "They prefer to achieve their results by...
- Part 2: Train the brain: Using decision making critiques to leverage lessons learned: Published at Police One
- "Wild animals are taken by scouting, by nets, by lying in wait, by stalking...
- "If one has never personally experience war...
- Chet Richards On: Boyd's Really Real OODA Loop
- Destruction and Creation
- A Video Biography of COL John Boyd
- Book Review: Imagine: How Creativity Works by Jonah Lehrer
- Book Review: Thinking Fast and Slow By Daniel Kahneman
- Train the brain: Using tactical decision games in training Published at POLICE ONE
- OODA Loops: The Explorer Mentality...And Recognizing Patterns of Behavior
- OODA Loop & Human Reaction Time
- The Leaders Ultimate Reward: 'I saw Someone Grow today, and I Helped'
- Where Have All the Warriors Gone? A Spot On Article, Every Cop Should Read
- Should Street Cops, Break Routines...and Think?
- Broken Windows...A Powerful Strategy, When Applied Robustly
- Lessons from SWAT the Street Cop Can Use on The Three Speeds of Operations
- Law enforcement interaction with the dangerously mentally ill
- Tip: Have an 'exit' strategy on vehicle stops
- What Those We Train Say About Us
- Mastering Tactics with Decision Making Exercises and Critiques
- The OODA loop, reaction time, and decision making
- Leaders share the faith...and promote heretics
- COL John Boyd: Building Snowmobiles and a Fine-tuned Situational Awareness
- Mindset and Winning is About Much More than Words, Isn't It?
- Interacting Tactfully and Tactically: Is This a Strategy, Law Enforcement Can Use?
- Emotion verses Strategy: Which Helps You Gain the Position of Advantage?
- "It Never Happens Here" So WHY Do We Train?
- Think 'FAST': A mnemonic to help keep you safe, by John Demand
- PoliceOne.Com Published: Are you prepared to adapt and win on the street?
- Understanding and Developing Adaptive Leadership During Pre-commissioning
- Book Review: If I Knew Then 2: Warrior Reflections
- A VISION AND THE MISSION FOR: THE FUTURE LAW ENFORCEMENT LEARNING ORGANIZATION
- Police Leaders as Educators and Trainers...Inspiring Cops to More Effective and Safe Policing
- You've Got To Have an Ace in the Hole. Are You Prepared to Adapt and Win on the Street?
- What has 2011 Taught You About Officer Safety and Effectiveness?
- Police One, column 'Staying Oriented' article #1: 'Red Teaming' the cop killer
- Mental Toughness and The Competitive Nature of Conflict
- Police Militarization, Professionalism, and the Balance of Persuasion and Force
- Mental Toughness and...The Power to Adapt
- Mental Toughness: Optimistic Enthusiasm as a Form of Realism
- Preparing for Crisis with Tactical Decision Games, After Action Reviews and Critical Question Mapping
- Great Recap of Boyd and Beyond 2011 By Scott Shipman
- Global Warrior Averting WWIII, John Poole's Latest Strategic and Tactical Insights to Protecting the Homeland
- Brain plasticity: A whole new idea for cops
- Boyd & Beyond is on for 14 & 15 October at Quantico.
- "SWARMING TACTICS" Published in the California Association of Tactical Officers official publication CATO NEWS
- Documentary: Massacre at Virginia Tech
- Book Review: TEMPO Timing, Tactics and Strategy in Narrative Driven Decision Making by Venkatesh Rao
- Fine Art, Fine Tuning Situation Awareness and Training Cops to See
- 15 Meters/11Seconds By C Flaherty and AR Green
- Too Focused? You Might Miss Something Important
- Dangerous Body Language: Digging Beyond What You See!
- Swarming & The Future of Conflict by John Arquilla and David Ronfeldt
- Swarming Tactics by Sid Heal
- More On Swarming Tactics...An Option For Law Enforcement
- Dangerous Body Language: Detecting Deception and Danger
- Cops Line of Duty Deaths Rising in 2011 "APPLYING"Lessons Learned
- Cops, Security, Citizens Need to Be Aware: Does the Climate & Environment Shift in the Wake of bin Laden's Death?
- Progress, Interrupt and Neutralize (P.I.N.) Swarming Techniques For The Tactician
- Should We Be Thinking Like the Bad Guys?
- Meet Officers Lewis and Clark-Exploring Situational Awareness
- Dangerous Body Language,The Boyd Cycle and Winning on the Street
- Dangerous Body Language: A Thousand Words...None Spoken! The Nose, Mouth and Lips
- The 10% of Mindset
- The 3 P's in Extreme Close Quarters Training: Pre-Assault Indicators, Precognitive Programming and Proximity
- Tactical IQ: Using "SURPRISE" to Set the Tempo of Confrontation.
- Tactical IQ: "FRICTION" Why is the Simplest Thing, So Difficult?
- Dangerous Body Language: A Thousand Words...None Spoken! Darting Eyes
- Operation Bold Strike: Follow Me Training Support Package
- Follow Me!!! Creating and Nurturing Tactical Decision Makers With Combat Tested Methodologies
- Training the Whole Circle: Blending Boyd's Cycle and Cooper's Color Codes
- Dangerous Body Language: A Thousand Words...None Spoken! "Gaze Avoidance"
- From OODA to AAADA ― A cycle for surviving violent police encounters
- Dangerous Body Language: A Thousand Words...None Spoken! The Thousand Yard Stare
- Baltimore Police Sergeants Training Using Adaptive Leadership Methodology with Don Vandergriff's AAR
- Achieving Outcomes on the Street with Integrity, Building Loyalty and Mutual Trust
- Intersecting Ideas from Cross Disciplines...and Taking Boyd's Theories Beyond
- Tactical IQ: Developing "Fingertip Feel" Shaping and Reshaping Dynamic Encounters and Gaining the Advantage
- Reducing Law Enforcement Misfortunes...What About the Street Officer?
- Can technology suck your brain dry?
- Organizational Culture: Is Yours Congruent with What You Do?
- Fighting Complacency Reminder: Nothing We Do is Routine, NOTHING!!!
- Street Level Red Teaming: The Cop Killer
- Street Level Red Teaming: Assessing The Situation From the Adversarial Point of View
- Take A.I.M. and Prepare To Win Dynamic Encounters
- Don't Charge Police for Mistakes
- What is a Threat?
- Benefits of Conditioning Our Decision Making...The Boyd Cycle
- Superior Situational Awareness and Decision Making...Attributes And Skills of Full Spectrum Officers
- Earning "The Right to Lead" With Character and Courage
- JUSTIFIED: Are You Serious? The Balancing Act of Persuasion, and Reasonable Force
- Adaptive Leader Methodology: An Alternative for Better Outcomes
- When Do We Teach the Basics?
- Evolving Threats Small Arms and Small Unit Swarming Tactics as Tools of Terror...Are We Up To the Challenge?
- Positive Leadership: Invest in People Building a Culture of Innovation
- Harnessing The Street Cops Wisdom: Taking Whole of Conflict...And Effective Full Spectrum Responses
- Beyond Active Response: An Operational Concept for Police Counterterrorism Response
- The Badge: Much More Than a Piece of Medal
- Wellbeing Check to Knife Attack: Anticipation-The Double Edged Sword and its Affect on Winning and Losing, Up Close and Personal
- Tactical IQ: Fast Transients Maneuvers and Manipulating the Tempo of Conflict
- Leadership By Wandering Around!
- Defeat into Victory: Battling a Tough Climate with Faith, Perseverance and Lessons Learned
- Evolving Threats and the Fourth Generation Warfare Problem Here at Home
- We were ready, they weren't...40 + Years after Newhall, Are We Applying Lessons Learned?
- When Violence Prevention Fails, Planning Must Enhance Strategy
- After Action Review: Is It a Tool Used to Learn and Become More Effective or a Tool Used to Punish?
- Maintaining Mental Calmness and Not Losing Our Cool
- Evolution of Strategy and Tactics to Ongoing Deadly Action "Active Shootings" and Operational Art
- Tactical IQ: Interaction, Insight and Imagination, and Initiative...The Building Blocks of Police Operational Art
- Coffee and Conversation: Is "Officer Friendly" a Factor to Consider in Engagements with Our Adversary?
- "Sharpening Our Orientation" and Reducing Officers Killed in the Line of Duty
- Coffee and Conversation: Police Make Mistakes But Seldom Admit Them! What's Reasonable?
- The Tactical Decision Maker: The Devil's Definitely in the Details
- "Self Awareness" The Forgotten Attribute of Decision Making
- Coffee and Conversation: Issues that Affect Law Enforcement and Security: Walking our Talk to Officer Safety
- Coffee and Conversation: Issues that Affect Law Enforcement and Security: The Inevitable Failure of Suburbia?
- Officer Created Jeopardy: Reduce it with a Strategic and Tactical Mind
- Law Enforcement and the Utility of Force...Why Cops Can't Shoot Like the Lone Ranger?
- Tactics: Applying Methods to Madness
- Dealing with Conflict, Violence and Crises: by Fred Leland
Reducing Law Enforcement Misfortunes...What About the Street Officer?
Submitted by Fred on Sun, 10/03/2010 - 11:58am.
“Criticism exists only to recognize the truth, not to act as judge” ~Carl von Clausewitz
Officers Walt Frago, Roger Gore, George Allan, and James Pence all California Highway Patrolman who died on April 5th 1970 while conducting a traffic stop, all be it one with known dangers. The report was at least one gun was brandished according to the victims statements after an altercation on the highway. These officers responded to and died in the line of duty on this day in one of law enforcement tragic misfortunes. Numerous lessons were analyzed. What have we learned? More importantly what have we learned and applied that makes the street cop better, more effective at what they do today?
In reality it was several guns Davis and Twinning possessed, a sawed off shotgun, a Colt 1911 .45 pistol, revolvers and rifles. In reality Bobby Davis and Jack Twinning were actually out training with firearms in preparations for robberies they wanted to commit. This day the two men would kill in total 4 officers.
Once the vehicle a red Pontiac was spotted driven by Bobby Davis and his fellow career criminal Jack Twinning in the passenger seat. Officers Walt Frago and Roger Gore stopped the vehicle and at first, it appeared as if Davis and Twinning would comply with demands to search their vehicle. Davis was ordered out of the vehicle, he complied and walked tot he rear as directed where he was searched by Roger Gore. Walt Frago walked towards the passenger door when Twinning jumped out the door and opened fire. Walt Frago went down from two fatal gunshot wounds. Twinning then adapted and focused his fire on Roger Gore, who drew his revolver and returned fire. This allowed time for Davis to create some distance draw his .38 and kill officer Gore.
Two cops killed in a matter of seconds was not the only misfortune this tragic day. things were about to get worse. Another 2 man patrol car occupied by Officers George Allan and James Pence, pulled up on the scene and observed what just took place. They immediately took cover behind their patrol car doors and began firing. Davis and twinning returned fire as well with the weapons they had and now the two revolves and the shotgun they took from officers Gore and Frago. This left both officers Allan and Pence at a severe disadvantage weapon wise. Quite simply they were outgunned and were also killed.
Twinning and Davis fled the scene,and split up. Twinning would eventually hold up in a house only miles away and end his own life once he was surrounded by police. Davis was captured and sent to prison for life.
This law enforcement tragedy known as the NEWHALL INCIDENT is a piece of law enforcement history and as such has taught us many lessons. Or has it? The Newhall Incident was the catalyst for OFFICER SURVIVAL TRAINING and supposedly a new respect for the adversary and what he is capable of when confronted by the police. We now know that criminals are not all poorly trained and police are not all “WELL TRAINED PROFESSIONLAS!”
I would like to know your thoughts on this questions.
- Are we 40 years After Newhall better trained than our adversaries?
- Has the policy and procedure culture of law enforcement actually made us more effective than the criminals who would do us or the citizenry we protect harm?
- Has the training we implemented over the last 40 years made better decision makers of street cops?
Here are the lesson from Newhall laid out in the book Deadly Force: From the Wild West To The Streets of Today by Chris McNab.
The CHP actually used the word “Newhall” as an acronym for key points to remember during traffic stops.
- N-Never approach a danger situation until you are adequately prepared and supported.
- E-Evaluate the offense and determine if you might just be dealing with something more dangerous than it looks.
- W-Wait for backup.
- H-Have a plan (in other words, don’t just wade into a situation without planning every move).
- A-Always maintain the advantage over the opponent.
- L-Look for the unusual.
- L-Leave the scene when in doubt.
Still today forty years after Newhall most law enforcement agencies have settled for mere adequacy in individual and small-team skills—we can do better.
Police officers often have little understanding of the reasons tasks were performed a particular way. We cops on the street have little understanding of tactics and operational art. Most cops on the street could recite these lessons learned from Newhall. BUT are we able to apply the lessons on the street?
Police officers are overly reliant on process, not focused enough on results (true in training, but also in planning and leading)
Most institutional training still has a mechanical, check-the-block feel and was focused on throughput. Meaning we focus on getting candidates through training no matter what instead of creating nurturing effective cop on the street. Most training was governed by inputs (hours, ammo, etc.) rather than outcomes or results.
There is still a pronounced tendency at all levels of law enforcement to control by rules—each problem seems to result in more rules (policies, regulations, directives, etc.)
Training methodology, combined with too many rules, has stifled initiative: With cops in training…Waiting To Be Told What To Do!This compensated for instructor inadequacies by providing them a script. This may have prevented failure in some, but it prevented excellence in many. Our training methods often not in harmony with human nature and rarely required real problem solving and initiative. Many law enforcement training programs misapplied stress: too much at the beginning, too little at the end.
Training provides little room for experimentation, mistakes. Mistakes is what we learn from. In training cops in training should be allowed to fail under pressure and learn from those lessons.
Most training still today, is focused on meeting minimum standards and avoiding failure, not on excellence and effectiveness on the street. faulty assumptions about how humans make decisions condition cops to fail.
Cops in training could succeed without understanding the why behind their decision and actions. A major problem with today's training.
Authority usually not aligned with responsibility, resulting in little accountability at all levels of policing.
How law enforcement training must shift
Law enforcement training must shift from training law enforcement officers how to apply solutions and enforce standards.To teaching officers how to frame problems and solve them. This is called “adaptive leadership” The main difference is our acceptance that we cannot predict all the types of problems our officers will have to solve. So we must train officers who can succeed in almost any situation.
Method of doing so is “Adaptive Leader Methodology (ALM)” Analogous to shifting
- From industrial-age mass production by fairly narrow experts
- To more individually tailored crafting by all-around artisans
To put things in context. Most law enforcement cultures developed in a fairly stable, predictable environment and are very good at teaching street officers how to respond to certain well-defined problems. Officer and Leader training focused on how to apply solutions and enforce standards—very effective as long as the situation was predictable. Over time, it fostered a culture of bureaucracy, rules, and engineered “best solutions”
Now the environment is changing rapidly and requires thinking leaders leading thinking officers. Street officer training must now focus on identifying the problem and solving it using the tools available. Law Enforcement must accept less standardization, more focus on achieving desired outcomes that requires:
- Leader judgment must replace detailed rules
- ALL TRAINING must be designed to include decision-making and develop judgment
- Law enforcement Leader training is the most important part, but by itself it is insufficient
Law Enforcement Approach
- Use real problems as the basis for training (LESSONS LEARNED FROM LAW ENFORCEMENT HISTORY)
- Generally start with the particular rather than the abstract theory
- Focus on the why, not just the what and how
- All teaching must combine doing with explaining and student understanding; all training requires employing skills to solve problems
- Standardize by outcomes, not by inputs or processes—allow both teachers and students the opportunity to try new approaches—minimize controls
- Create an environment in which it’s ok to make mistakes—penalize only failure to think or failure to try
- Constant feedback is essential—and must be acted upon
- Assess what’s important rather than what’s easy to measure
- Align incentives. What’s rewarded? What’s penalized?
- Cross-share what’s worked and what hasn’t at all levels
The knowledge and lessons learned of Newhall and the countless other incidents where cops have lost their lives in the performance of their duties over the last forty years and beyond, must be brought to a much higher level through training. To achieve application of what we know, to circumstances on the street, we must start walking our talk towards training outcomes. Is what we are teaching making cops effective on the street in dangerous dynamic encounters?
Trainers, don’t tell people how to solve a problem, instead allow cops in training to take ownership through discovery. Let them try it themselves. Let each individual do as much of it (SKILLS BEING DEVELOPED) himself as he’s capable of. Indeed make sure they understand the theory…sometime in the process and yes mastery of the basics is crucial to survival and winning on the street. Use the 70/30 principle, 70% of time on mastering basics; ~30% of time on applying them, incorporating problem solving. Begin with no stress, then add increased difficulty as the student gains in capability.
Expectations of leaders:
Whoever’s in charge must know: What he’s trying to accomplish (what’s the outcome?)How he’ll know if it’s working. All leaders must be able: To do the task themselves. To explain why it’s done that way and to teach it.
I have written about the lesson from Newhall in the past. Their are numerous lesson here we must focus our efforts on and at the same time understand that when dealing with people, complexity is always part of the equation. So we must train to a level of effectiveness that allows for full spectrum law enforcement officers to deliver full spectrum responses.
The solution is found in our collective ability to constantly strive to be better at what we do and learn from experience, to include experience from others. Many have paid the ultimate sacrifice by making mistakes and having them exploited by those who would do them harm. Some questions and points to explore in reviewing law enforcement case studies, to help in mapping out law enforcement misfortunes and applying the lessons learned I took and adapted from the outstanding book, Military Misfortunes by Elliot Cohen and John Gooch they are;
- What was the failure?
- What were the critical tasks that went unfulfilled or incomplete?
- We must conduct a layered analysis examining the behavior of different levels of the organization and their relative contribution to the law enforcement misfortune. This procedure leads to the fourth step.
- The drawing of an analytical matrix , a simplified chart of failures and lessons learned that presents the key problems leading to law enforcement misfortune. From these lessons we derive our:
- Pathways to misfortune, the larger causes of the failure in question.
These mistakes and lessons learned from them have been written and talked about for 40 years now and yet many of those killed in the line of duty today perish from the same mistakes being repeated again and again. Lets get better at what we do. You owe it to those you protect, those you love and care for. And you owe it to yourselves!
“Strategy is a mental tapestry of changing intentions for harmonizing and focusing our efforts as a basis for realizing some aim or purpose in an unfolding and often unforeseen world of many bewildering events and many contending interests.” ~COL John Boyd
I look forward to your feedback on this important topic. I encourage both positive and negative feedback, it only helps in all of us, learning. Discussion and debate on these matters only makes us better at what we do. Please get engaged and learn. Your life and the life of your fellow officers may depend on it.
|Reducing Law Enforcement Misfortunes final draft.pdf||98.8 KB|